Our next door neighbors just closed on there new home and it is the same exact color as ours. There trim work is a slightly lighter color. Different front elevation than ours, but otherwise almost the same house. Could care less. The only time we even thought about it was when the new owners brought it up. They are great neighbors and the exterior paint doesn't mean a thing to either my wife nor I. Go with the color you like, even if it is the same as next door. Too many other more important things in life to worry about than if the color is the same as next door. Quite frankly, we felt it a compliment our neighbors painted there's the same color, particularly the fact that there house came in at around 2 million.

Some Homeowner Associations have guidelines about neighboring homes sharing too similar color palettes. If you have a HOA, you might want to double check.

Even if there isn't HOA influencing color choices, I make an effort to differentiate to whatever degree possible from neighboring homes. There are a lot of colors out there to choose from, espeically a lot of very nice exterior greens. You mention the homes being consistent in style and that would give me pause as well. The trees would help to a certain degree, but still I think for the most part people like to think that their homes are unique and have some individuality. You also mention that the neighborhood overall is ecclectic, another point to consider. Will all the other houses own their style so to speak making you and your neighbor's house then look out of place because your homes would be the only ones that are similar in style and identical in color? Lastly, do you know what your neighbor would think of your painting your house the same color? Would be unfortunate if she/he didn't take the imitation as flattery and have it cause a bit of tension between the two of you.

You may or may not have already considered most of these points. Just trying to help you think it through. :-)

I have to agree with funcolors. It would be different for the two houses to be the same beige, but for them both to be what sounds like a pretty distinctive green may look funny, and they really may not be the laid-back type who wouldn't care. There are so many nice paint colors in the world - could you possibly use your green on the trim or something?

I have to admit that I wouldn't love it if my next door neighbors painted their house the same color as mine. My house is pale green with ivory trim. If my neighbor painted it a medium green with a different color trim, I'd probably be okay with it. But I wouldn't like it if it were essentially the same color scheme as my house.

It wouldn't ruin my relationship with neighbors, and it certainly wouldn't be something that I stressed over. But I wouldn't love it.

Thanks for the input. I am going to try to avoid both neighbors' paint colors, although since they both use mid-tone neutrals it is knocking out a lot of choices!

FWIW - We recently moved from a community (Florida) that had FOUR houses in a row the SAME color, one of which was OURS. Sure they were slightly different styles and two had a slight different trim color" but even three had same color roofs. Back in 1988 it started as (as was still supposed to be) "deed restricted" with H.O.A. but the HOA "dissolved" years ago and I guess "anything goes" as they say.... the lack of ANY "enforced" HOA was one of the main reasons (in addition to sloppy, un-cut lawns, vehicles and boats all over the streets, rowdy kids, etc.) we only stayed there one year then moved out !!
Anyway, back ON-topic...... the "look" of FOUR houses the SAME COLOR was the strangest thing we ever saw, unfortunately down here in ever-growing Florida, it is very, very common, and when on a "zero-lot-line" (ONLY 7 1/2 feet TOTAL BETWEEN BOTH HOUSES) it really looks strange.

How close a match? If it's a color you really love, I'd take your chip over to your neighbor's house and actually compare. If yours is off a few shades, I think you'll be fine. If it's exactly the same, then go off a few shades or tones.